How to make a Top 10 list in 5 minutes

We are curious creatures, us humans, we seem intent on categorising everything. I mean the Victorians collected butterflies, Hippies collected vinyl and us modern types collect tags. We have even developed a new word to happily categorise this new ‘thing’, Folksonomy.

A folksonomy is an Internet-based information retrieval methodology consisting of collaboratively generated, open-ended labels that categorize content such as Web pages, online photographs, and Web links.

I notice more and more over the last few months that as the web has evolved into this supposed super hive of interesting things that we are more and more bombarded by ‘blogs’ with ‘Top 10’ this or ‘How to’ that. This got me wondering about how we as people are really using this new found resource. By using these new fangled tagging systems are we in essence just collecting bits of information and simply becoming a collection of refence people? Why not teach our kids how to find information using a resource rather than actually teaching them the information first hand?

You can’t help but feel its a dimension of fashion. Hell even I have this blog here, so it is probably quite hypocritical to talk about trendiness and fashion. Having said that it is more than apparent that the 90’s internet bubble is simply repeating its self but only with more pastel colours, reflections and participation. I guess these are the things that most would ascribe to Web2.0. As ever people will not be constrained to a preformed ideal of any kind and already there are a variety of spoof Web2.0 sites and jokes springing up. I do hope that these fashions do blow over and we see some real innovation in the way that people actually interact with computers.

Will any of these new interactions change the way that we process data? Will tags stick? Personally I think that they are quite a solid idea. However it does seem that they have serious flaws, mainly driven by the people that use them. As mentioned in the Wikipedia article, tag pollution and such can occur within the system. A similar thing appears with RSS feeds. We are so intent on having information at our fingertips that we perhaps don’t consider the quality of that information or the validity of it’s source. Instead we simply tag it or save it, perhaps never to be seen or read ever again. I recall reading a comment somewhere that del.icio.us was more “Write many, Read once” or something to that effect.

Perhaps we are better off simply remembering where we found information or the methods used to find it again, rather than the information its self. After all, the knowledge of how to find something can surely lead to you being able to retain a larger amount of knowledge? It might well be that this is the future of the internet as a knowledge repository. How we access and use that information, I think, will have a significant impact on both us as people and the socieities that we permeate.

  • Listening to: The faint hum of servers in a hot office.
Advertisements

One thought on “How to make a Top 10 list in 5 minutes

  1. Many people do categorize things, that’s because when we do so things appear clearer to us. Its not only us humans who do these, animals do so as well; take bees, they have a section in their hives to store food, while another section to breed, etc…
    i think that the main problem is that nowadays people have the ability to collect too many information too quickly and easily on the internet, which leads to them not remembering the information they found and thinking to themselves “I’ll come back to it later” (but then they forget about it)
    And I think you are absolutely right, more and more people have started to put own views on the internet, such as web blog and this is slowly changing the internet to not only a “normal” library, but it is also a library for their opinions to be displayed and time and time again we can see people adopting foolish ideas just because they have been displayed on the internet. Luckily there is only a minority of them ^^

Comments are closed.